The most common objection to standardisation is that it kills initiative and expertise, and experience points the other way. Without a standard you cannot improve, because you have nothing to improve from; you can only vary. Taiichi Ohno made that recognition one of the foundations of the Toyota Production System.
Why the objection deserves to be taken seriously
Tell an experienced employee that the work is to be standardised, and you will usually meet resistance: that the task is more complicated than that, that the experience cannot be written down, and that the flexibility will be lost. The objections are real, and they are at the same time a reliable sign that the standardisation has not been explained properly.
A standard, after all, is not a description of how a capable manager thinks the work ought to be done. It is a written record of the best known way of doing it, as that way looks to the people who actually do the work. To which comes one decisive addition: a standard is temporary, and it applies until a better way is found.
Ohno and Toyota: the standard as the starting point for improvement
Taiichi Ohno, who more than anyone built the Toyota Production System, put the point briefly: "Without standards, there can be no improvement." The sentence is not about controlling what people do; it is about improvement requiring a fixed point to improve from. If two employees solve the same task in different ways and the result varies, there is no way of knowing whether the variation came from the method or from the person. You cannot improve something you cannot repeat.
"Without standards, there can be no improvement."
— Taiichi Ohno, Toyota Production System
What standards actually free up
Think of a newly trained employee starting in a department without standards. The next months are spent asking colleagues, rediscovering what others already know, and avoiding mistakes that are never documented. An experienced colleague spends time answering questions, correcting variations and making sure things end up right.
Now put a good standard into the same department. The new employee becomes productive sooner, and the experienced one can spend their capacity on improving the work rather than on explaining it again. The organisation stops rediscovering what it already knew and starts building on top of it instead. That is the freedom a standard offers: freedom from having to make the same choices afresh every day.
Kaizen requires a standard
Kaizen, meaning continuous improvement, is one of the basic ideas in Lean thinking, and kaizen is only possible where there is a standard to improve from. Masaaki Imai, who popularised the term, was clear that standardisation and kaizen are two sides of the same coin. You standardise the best you know; you improve it; you standardise the new; you improve again. The PDCA cycle is the formalised version of that alternation. Remove the standard, and the cycle breaks at the first step.
Bad standards exist, and they are an argument for better ones
There are genuinely bad standards: too bureaucratic, too detailed and written by people who do not know the work. They create resistance, and rightly so. The answer is rarely to do without standards, but to write them better, which means writing them with the people who do the work, putting the weight on what actually varies and causes problems, and agreeing to revise them as more becomes known.
To see what a usable standard looks like in practice, a standard work template is a good starting point. It is built so it can be filled in by the team itself, not imposed from above.
✓The most important takeaways
- →Without a standard you cannot improve, only vary. That is Ohno's point, and it still holds.
- →A standard is the best known way of doing something, not the only way, and not the final one.
- →Standards free up capacity: they reduce time spent rediscovering the same thing and free energy for improvement.
- →Kaizen and standardisation are preconditions for each other rather than opposites.
Sources
- Ohno, T. (1988). Toyota Production System: Beyond Large-Scale Production. Productivity Press.
- Imai, M. (1986). Kaizen: The Key to Japan's Competitive Success. McGraw-Hill.
- Imai, M. (1997). Gemba Kaizen: A Commonsense Approach to a Continuous Improvement Strategy. McGraw-Hill.
The references show the professional basis. Sources are reproduced in their original language.