LeadershipBy Henrik3 min28 June 2026

Lean runs aground on management routines

What happens to management's daily behaviour once the project ends decides whether the improvements hold

LeanLeadershipAnchoring

That Lean works is well documented through decades of research and on factory floors around the world, and yet one keeps meeting the sentence: we tried Lean, and it did not work for us. As a diagnosis it is wrong, and it costs more than the consulting project that was lost, because it leaves the organisation with a lesson that runs the next improvement aground before it has begun.

What actually runs aground

Lean programmes don't run aground on 5S, VSM or board meetings. They run aground on what is required to keep them alive: management's daily behaviour. When top management approves a Lean initiative and then carries on with the same meeting structures, the same measurement systems and the same reactive logic, it sends a signal far stronger than any kick-off meeting. The signal reads: this is something for production, not for us.

MIT researchers Nelson Repenning and John Sterman have described the mechanism precisely in what they call the capability trap: under pressure, organisations fall back on what they know, namely quick fixes and heroics, rather than investing in the systems and routines that make problems rarer over time. The paradox is that the more there is burning, the harder it becomes to set aside time to build the fire alarm, and the more rarely the alarm gets built, the more things keep burning.

"Under pressure, organisations revert to what they know, and that prevents them from building what removes the pressure."

— Repenning & Sterman, MIT

The visible and the invisible leader

One can distinguish between two kinds of leadership in a Lean effort. The visible kind turns up at the kick-off, approves the budget and sits in on the status meeting. The invisible kind decides what actually happens when nobody is watching: who gets praised, what gets deprioritised, which problems get asked about, and which are allowed to slide past.

It is the invisible kind that a Lean effort lives on: the manager who turns up at the board in a busy week as well, who asks questions rather than dictating the answer, and who reads a deviation note as information rather than as criticism. The tools are aids, and aids last only as long as somebody keeps using them.

Deming's point that never went out of fashion

W. Edwards Deming argued systematically that the vast majority of problems in an organisation stem from the system management has built and is responsible for, rather than from the employees. From that followed his conclusion: an organisation is not improved by talking to the employees, but by changing the systems and structures that shape their behaviour, and only management can carry out that task. Shook's NUMMI example illustrates the point: the employees who had worked at one of GM's worst-performing plants built, under Toyota's management system, cars of a quality that ranked among the best in North America, without the workforce having been essentially replaced.

What it takes in practice

This is no charge against managers, but a clarification of what the task consists of. A Lean programme is in reality a leadership development programme, and it presupposes that the managers change their own routines and not merely those of the employees. The board meeting has to become something they turn up to because it belongs to leading in this particular organisation, rather than something they attend for as long as they keep being invited.

When a Lean programme does not hold, little is learned from asking whether Lean worked. The question worth asking is what happened to management's daily behaviour once the project was closed, and most organisations can answer that one themselves.

✓The most important takeaways

  • →Lean programmes rarely run aground on the method. They run aground because management's daily behaviour does not change enough.
  • →The strongest signal a management team sends lies in what it does, not in what it says.
  • →The capability trap: under pressure we revert to what we know, and that prevents us from building what reduces the pressure.
  • →A Lean effort is in reality a leadership development programme. Treated as a production project, it stands a good chance of running aground.

Sources

  1. Repenning, N. P. & Sterman, J. D. (2001). Nobody Ever Gets Credit for Fixing Problems That Never Happened. California Management Review, 43(4), 64–88.
  2. Deming, W. E. (1986). Out of the Crisis. MIT Press.
  3. Shook, J. (2010). How to Change a Culture: Lessons from NUMMI. MIT Sloan Management Review, 51(2).

The references show the professional basis. Sources are reproduced in their original language.

Get the next insight in your inbox

1-2 educational articles a month on Lean, OEE and anchored operations. Only knowledge you can use.

No spam. Unsubscribe at any time. See our privacy policy.

From insight to action

Do you recognise the pattern in your own operations?

An initial conversation, no obligation. We map your situation and tell you honestly whether — and how — there is something to gain.