When something goes wrong, most of us look for the person who did it wrong. The reaction is a human one, and it usually leads somewhere unhelpful. W. Edwards Deming estimated that around 94 per cent of the quality problems in an organisation arise from the system rather than from the people working in it, and that finding calls for a different kind of leadership than the hunt for whoever is to blame.
The instinct that costs dearly
An order arrives late. A customer complains about a fault. An employee makes the same mistake twice. The first management reaction is almost always the same: who was responsible? Who made the mistake? What do we do about that person?
The reaction is understandable, since we are used to thinking in individual causes and individual solutions. The trouble is that the question leads to a place where the answer is rarely found. Few problems in an organisation have their cause in the individual; they have it in the way the work is arranged.
Deming's observation
W. Edwards Deming spent most of his career documenting what most managers did not want to hear: that the overwhelming part of the variation in an organisation's results stems from the system rather than from the individuals who work within it. He first put the share at around 85 per cent and later revised it upward to 94 in Out of the Crisis, and the figure is quoted more often than it is acted on. Deming himself was plain that industry spent too much energy finding scapegoats and too little examining the processes and structures in which the faults arose. He counted the annual rating of individual performance among what he called the deadly diseases of management, precisely because it rests on the belief that an organisation improves by rewarding the best and punishing the worst rather than by rebuilding the system they all work in.
"What a person is able to achieve is largely governed by the system, and the system is the responsibility of management."
— Rendered after W. Edwards Deming, Out of the Crisis
What it means in practice
Once a mistake has been made, the useful question is not who made it, but what in our own system made it possible, and what we do to remove that possibility. The logic is a different one, and it is neither lax nor a way of dissolving responsibility. It is on the contrary more demanding, because it places the responsibility with those who can actually change the system, which is to say with management.
This way of thinking is the core of the Toyota Production System and of all good operational leadership. When a problem arises, the reflex of Toyota leaders is to go to the processes, not to the person. Was the standard clear enough? Was there time to do it correctly? Was the fault visible before it reached the next step? These are the questions that lead to changes in the system, and those are the changes that stay.
What happens when you replace the person instead
Organisations that react first and foremost with individual accountability, in the form of warnings, reassignment and closer monitoring, see a pattern that repeats itself: the same faults return with new faces. It is the strongest sign available that the cause lies in the system, since replacing the person leaves the arrangement of the work untouched.
This is no excuse for a lack of individual accountability, but a clarification of what accountability looks like at each of the two levels. The employee is accountable for following the standards and procedures that have been given. The manager is accountable for the standards being clear, realistic and possible to follow in the reality where they have to be followed. Standard work is the concrete tool for making the latter visible and operational.
✓The most important takeaways
- →Deming estimated that around 94 per cent of quality problems arise from the system rather than from the individual employees, and the figure is still underrated.
- →Don't ask "who did it wrong?" Ask "what in the system allowed it?"
- →Organisations that mainly react with individual accountability see the same faults return with new faces.
- →Management is accountable for the system. That is a more demanding understanding of accountability than finding the person at fault, and it is also the only one that moves anything.
Sources
- Deming, W. E. (1986). Out of the Crisis. MIT Press. — see The W. Edwards Deming Institute.
- Liker, J. K. (2004). The Toyota Way. McGraw-Hill.
- Shook, J. (2010). How to Change a Culture: Lessons from NUMMI. MIT Sloan Management Review, 51(2).
The references show the professional basis. Sources are reproduced in their original language.
