StrategyBy Henrik5 min27 October 2026

Quality presupposes that you have chosen your customers

Why the decision about whom you intend to be the right supplier for belongs with the board and not in operations

StrategyQualityOperations

The factory that was meant to do everything

Wickham Skinner described the problem as early as 1974, and the description has held up remarkably well. A factory serving markets with different competitive conditions loses efficiency overall, because the requirements pull against each other in ways that largely cannot be reconciled. His recommendation was not to run faster. It was to narrow the ground, so that each unit worked with a manageable range of products and markets rather than making itself available for all of them.

The point is often read as a question of capacity, and then it disappears. More machines and more people do not solve it, because the conflict lies in the priorities. An operation set up for short lead times carries inventory, changeover readiness and spare capacity that an operation optimised for the lowest unit cost would systematically remove as waste. Both dispositions are right, each for its own customer, and that is precisely why they cannot be housed in the same factory without someone paying for the compromise.

Three questions that reveal whether the choice has been made

They can be taken at a management meeting, and disagreement about the answers is itself informative.

  • •Which type of customer would we let go of first if we were forced to choose? And would sales, operations and management give the same answer if we each wrote it down separately before talking?
  • •What are we deliberately worse at than our competitors? If the answer is “nothing”, the company has not made a choice, and the individual order makes it instead, order by order.
  • •Which yes did we say last year that should have been a no? What did it cost down in operations, and who in the building noticed the bill?

Why what you give up is what makes a position durable

Michael Porter argued in 1996 that it is precisely the trade-offs that make a strategic position worth having. A position that does not require giving anything up can be copied by any competitor, and then what you have is an improvement everyone adopts sooner or later rather than a position. What cannot be copied without cost are the choices where you have deliberately made yourself worse at one thing in order to become appreciably better at another.

In a management group that sentence sounds like an admission, which is why it is rarely said out loud. A company that cannot account for what it is deliberately worse at than its competitors has either not chosen or chosen without acknowledging it. Both states have the same effect: in practice the choice gets made by whichever order happens to come in, and by whichever salesperson happens to answer the phone.

Four stages, and where most quality functions stand

Robert Hayes and Steven Wheelwright described four stages in 1985 for the role operations plays in a company's competitiveness. At the first stage operations is internally neutral, and its job is to avoid causing trouble while competitiveness is sought elsewhere. At the second it is externally neutral and follows the industry. At the third it is internally supportive, so that operational decisions are aligned with the chosen strategy. At the fourth it is externally supportive and helps create the advantage, because it is in the room when the strategy is set.

The model gives a usable vocabulary for a widespread condition. A quality function whose job is to ensure that nothing goes wrong, and which measures itself on whether the procedures were followed, sits at the first stage. It does its work correctly, yet it is not present where it is decided what is to be done correctly. That is the same point as in the claim that quality is not a system, put in a model from operations management: a function that never leaves the first stage can be professionally beyond reproach and at the same time irrelevant to whether the company wins or loses customers.

Who is in the room when the customers are chosen

You can read your own stage off a single question: who is in the room when it is decided which customers the company intends to be the right one for? If operations and quality have the decision reported to them afterwards and are then asked to make it work, the company sits at the first or second stage, whatever certificates hang in reception. What settles it is how early in the process operations is asked, rather than how the organisation chart looks.

The cost of asking too late rarely appears in the accounts as a loss. It appears as busyness: changeovers that take longer than planned, rush orders that push other orders aside, and inventory that grows to cover a promise nobody had costed. It looks like trouble in operations, it gets treated as trouble in operations, and so people work harder at something that is not the cause. That misdiagnosis is the most expensive one there is in a manufacturing company, because it renders every effort ineffective.

A company that has not chosen its customers effectively promises every single customer exactly what that customer asks for. The bill for that promise lands in operations, where it is read as poor efficiency. Choosing your customers is therefore no limit on growth; it is a condition for quality work being able to succeed at all, since you cannot measure yourself against an expectation you have not decided to meet.

✓What matters most

  • →Quality measured against the customer's expectation says nothing until you have said which customer.
  • →An operation required to serve markets with opposite demands loses efficiency overall. The conflict lies in the priorities, not in the capacity.
  • →Trade-offs are what make a position durable. If the company cannot say what it is deliberately worse at, it has not chosen.
  • →A quality function that measures itself on whether the procedures were followed sits at the first of four stages: professionally in order and outside the decision that settles anything.
  • →The test is who is in the room when the customers are chosen.

Sources

  1. Skinner, W. (1974). The Focused Factory. Harvard Business Review, 52(3), 113–121. On the factory serving markets with irreconcilable demands.
  2. Porter, M. E. (1996). What Is Strategy?. Harvard Business Review, 74(6), 61–78. On trade-offs as what makes a position durable.
  3. Hayes, R. H. & Wheelwright, S. C. (1985). Competing Through Manufacturing. Harvard Business Review, 63(1). The four stages of the role operations plays in competitiveness.

All three articles sit behind Harvard Business Review’s paywall. The arguments are rendered after the authors’ own formulations of them rather than quoted verbatim, and the year of Hayes and Wheelwright’s four-stage model is given in the literature as both 1984 and 1985.

Get the next insight in your inbox

1-2 educational articles a month on Lean, OEE and anchored operations. Only knowledge you can use.

No spam. Unsubscribe at any time. See our privacy policy.

From insight to action

Do you recognise the pattern in your own operations?

An initial conversation, no obligation. We map your situation and tell you honestly whether — and how — there is something to gain.