Most manufacturers hold board meetings, and rather fewer have a daily discipline that actually drives the improvements forward. The difference rarely lies in the design of the boards. It lies in the structure, in the rhythm and in the management behaviour that surrounds them.
Why board meetings lose their energy
The sequence is a familiar one. The company invests in fine visual boards, a meeting is held to set the routine going, and the first weeks run on high energy. Then the decline sets in: the meetings begin a little late, the figures on the board are a few days old, the problems get discussed without anyone acting on them, and the managers drop by when there is time.
How the three levels fit together
Daily management that works rarely consists of one meeting. It consists of three meetings at one level each, held in sequence, where a problem that cannot be solved at one level has an agreed route on to the next.
Tier 1: team-leader level (daily, 10-15 min)
- •Held at the production line's board
- •Review of yesterday's key figures and today's plan
- •Identifying deviations and immediate blockers
- •Passing on the problems the team cannot solve itself
Tier 2: department-manager level (daily, 15-20 min)
- •Receives escalations from Tier 1
- •Prioritises resources across teams
- •Coordinates support from maintenance, quality, logistics
- •Passes on to Tier 3 where necessary
Tier 3: leadership level (daily/weekly, 20-30 min)
- •Strategic overview of operational status
- •Decisions that require a management mandate
- •The allocation of resources across departments
- •Follow-up on the improvements under way
The three rules that cannot be relaxed
The Lean literature and practical experience agree on three rules that decide whether the daily discipline holds:
- •Fixed times. The meetings begin at the same time every day, however busy things are.
- •The manager is present. The department manager has to stand at the board for the Tier 2 meeting rather than merely look in.
- •Action the same day. A problem found in the morning must have an owner and a next step before the end of the shift.
To go from theory to practice, you can download our Tier meeting template and read the full Daily Management guide. The point is the same all the way through: the structure only works once the management behaviour is anchored in operations.
✓How to get started
- →Start with Tier 1, and get that level working before adding more layers.
- →Measure what share of the meetings is actually held. The figure often comes as a surprise.
- →Practise running the meeting. A good board meeting needs someone who can keep it on track.
- →Write the routes onward down, so everyone knows when a problem goes up a level, and who receives it.
Sources and further reading
- Mann, D. (2010). Creating a Lean Culture: Tools to Sustain Lean Conversions (2nd ed.). Productivity Press.
- Rother, M. & Shook, J. (1999). Learning to See. Lean Enterprise Institute.
- Lean Enterprise Institute — lean.org.
The references show the professional basis. Sources are reproduced in their original language.